Home » Blog » “Carry Your Own Bag!”: Raising Kids Who Aren’t Helpless


“Carry Your Own Bag!”: Raising Kids Who Aren’t Helpless

BlogCarnivalParenting2Welcome to the final installment of the Around The World in Six Weeks Parenting Carnival!  We’ve loved reading and sharing Christine Gross-Loh’s book Parenting Without Borders: Surprising Lessons Parents Around the World Can Teach Us with you.

We’re excited to begin our next selection, Playing to Win: Raising Children in a Competitive Culture by Hilary Levey Friedman. The book analyzes our competitive culture of afterschool activities for even young children, from dance to soccer and chess. Please check out our Facebook page for our new Brilliant Book Club: Illuminating Reads For Parents. If you like to talk about books and hear what other parents are reading, this may be the community for you!

Please read the other posts in this week’s carnival:

Sarah from Left Brain Buddha: “Character, Compassion, and Confucius: On the Yin and Yang of Parenting

Stephanie from Mommy, For Real: “Shaping Our Children’s Character: How Much Molding Is Too Much?

Lauren from Omnimom: “My Biggest Parenting Critic Right Now? My Eight Year Old

Debra from Urban Moo Cow: “Please Don’t Make Me Explain the Importance of Thank You


I have a teacher confession: As a fifth and sixth grade teacher, I would often do my students’ “classroom jobs” for them.

If you are the parent of an elementary or middle school student, you may have heard of job boards. On a bulletin board, all sorts of jobs are listed — from Class Librarian (in charge of putting back classroom library books) to Paper Passer (in charge of passing back papers). There are enough jobs for each kid, and students rotate through them.

In theory, I supported the idea of these jobs: they would help teach kids about responsibility, build a sense of community in the classroom. However, I was also a bit of a control freak about my classroom, and ten year olds are not known for completing all tasks completely and neatly.  So I would just do it myself. If the classroom library got into disarray — if the titles were no longer sorted by genre and then in alphabetical order the way that I wanted — I would fix it. Most of the time when I wanted papers to be put back into folders properly, I would do it myself. I would even stack the chairs myself because I wanted it done a certain way.

I started noticing that other teachers did not do what I was doing: micromanaging the classroom. My teaching partner, a man in his fifties, left his students in charge of all the errands and tasks in his classroom. The class made a big deal of learning all the jobs in the beginning of the year.  Later in the year, sometimes his classroom library was a mess. Or the juice wouldn’t be returned to the kitchen after snack. But he didn’t their chores for them. Instead, he tried to give consequences for neglecting responsibilities.

So the next year I gave up a little control. And the kids started to take their jobs seriously. (Maybe a little too seriously… There began to be arguments about whose turn it was to do more favored jobs and who was better at their jobs.)

Despite the good intentions of many teachers, Christine Gross-Loh’s section in her book on building character in kids makes it clear that parents throughout every culture have the primary responsibility for teaching responsibility to their children. And I must say that, as a teacher, I noticed — just as Gross-Loh did — that many American parents sometimes don’t do the best job.

There was the parent who would call and demand a conference about my new seating chart that placed her daughter next to a child with mild autism, and she wanted her daughter moved because her daughter found his rocking to be upsetting. There was the parent who actually drew and gave me her own diagrams of where she wanted her child placed in homeroom, as well as in every class during the day, from art to computer class.  There was the parent who hid in the bushes (taking notes) during recess because she wanted to keep track of who her son played with at recess.  There was the parent that I found afterschool going through my classroom waste basket because she was looking for notes that another student may have written about her son so that she could call and confront the other parent. Nearly every day there were parents who called to give me reasons why their child couldn’t complete their homework and shouldn’t be penalized (up too late at a sports game, visiting relatives, extra homework in another class).

Japanese girl walking back home
Japanese girl walking back home (Photo credit: Héctor de Pereda)

But it’s also not always their fault either. Schools and other parents make it difficult to allow kids to have the sorts of responsibilities that children do in other cultures. At my school in Cambridge, in a lovely, safe and low traffic neighborhood, even kids in fifth grade had to be walked home by an adult, even if they lived on the same street. The first time I was told this, during my first days of teaching there, I laughed. Could that possibly be right? Ten or eleven year olds can’t ride home on their bikes when they live a few minutes away? Quite a difference from my own childhood when, even as a first grader, I walked home about a half mile by myself, and no one thought it was remotely strange.

Now, as a parent, I find myself in the same bind that I did as a beginning teacher. I know that even my two year old can start helping out a little bit, carrying his own little backpack or putting away a few of his toys. But it’s just so much easier to do it yourself. So I feed him his dinner instead of letting him feed himself. I carry him too often because it takes too long for him to walk down the street himself, as he stops at every pinecone and every bush and tree. I brush his teeth, instead of letting him do it, because it’s faster and easier.

What does Christine Gross-Loh suggest for American parents?  How can we get out of this national situation of raising helpless kids?

1. Do not make chores optional. You are not doing your kids any favors by keeping them from work. Children are naturally and universally eager to help out when they are very young. But this changes as they get older. As Gross-Loh says,

 “But when we ignore our children’s eagerness to participate when they are younger, they internalize the idea that contributing is unimportant and that they are helpless. They also begin to expect that things will be done for them.”

2. Give your child clear expectations about how they can help out the family.  Teach your kids clearly that they will be expected to take care of their own things. Kids will need a lot of reminders, patience, and guidance when they are little.

3. Be age-appropriate in your expectations, and allow older kids to take care of younger ones. Other cultures understand that shared care-giving is an important way of teaching self-reliance and nurturing. In other cultures, from Europe to Central America, they expect more from their children physically, Gross-Loh points out, but do not overestimate what they are capable of intellectually. (Apparently — gulp! — in other cultures, kids don’t experience the dreaded “Terrible Twos,” which we know all too well in my household.) They are treated with kindness and patience, with the understanding that they will understand rules and mature as they get older.

Laos: Nutritious meals are bringing more child...4. Let your kid get around by herself as much as possible. Not only is fresh air, activity, and exercise good for children, but children learn confidence when they are allowed to go from place to place on their own.  Honestly, some of the most magical moments of my elementary school years were those 15 to 20 minutes when I walked with my little brother. We could choose to cut through the woods, running home through the trees. We could choose to take the road. We could chase each other and play tag all the way home. Most of the walk home was up a steep mountain, and we could run up the mountain without even needing to catch our breaths.

In most countries, children walking home from school is a normal sight to see on a weekday afternoon. In Japan, for example, very young children are taught in school about how to be safe during their walks to school. In all cultures, it is expected that kids need practice and guidance to help them be more independent.

What are ways that you teach your children to be responsible, helpful, and independent? How does your children’s sense of responsibility or level of helplessness compare to your own childhood experiences?

Join The Brilliant Book Club on Facebook!

Enhanced by Zemanta


  1. I am sooooo with you about doing the jobs yourself, fellow control freak! This is why I never have a student aide at school…. I want things done exactly and perfectly MY WAY! 🙂

    I agree with you about giving our kids more responsibility. Like walking to school – we live close enough that my daughter could, but I worry about her doing it, and no one else does….

    After reading this chapter, I am planning on being more deliberate about giving kids chores and responsibilities around the home, rather than just requesting help at random times.
    I really enjoyed reading these last few chapters!
    Sarah @ LeftBrainBuddha recently posted…Character, Compassion, and ConfuciusMy Profile

  2. mary kathryn says:

    It’s a long-range process, especially with our own kids. My s-i-l had her kids doing all manner of household chores when they were VERY young. They broke many things! Another s-i-l wouldn’t let her boys do any laundry EVER (even when they’re 20!), any cooking, any cleaning up. Both positions can be unreasonable, but the child who can care for himself when he’s a man has been given a gift by his parents. Over the growing-up years, the work will be done poorly, indifferently, sloppily, but that’s part of the training. With children, the goal is not ALWAYS a clean house; the goal is a learning child.

    In the classroom: I taught high school, and the classroom was mine. These kinds of things shift and change as kids age. The kind of ownership and responsibility I wanted for my 17 year olds to learn pertained to their academic work, not the condition of my white board or my trash can. By the time they’re 17, you assume they know how to keep themselves and their surroundings tidy. High school teachers owe elementary teachers a huge debt of gratitude for instilling those very qualities you describe! But as your stories demonstrate — Oh!!! The parents!!!
    mary kathryn recently posted…Reading L’AbriMy Profile

  3. Momma, PhD says:

    I think I’m doing the same for my kids as my parents did for me. I encourage my 3yo daughter to take care of herself- when she loses something, I say, “It’s not my toy, I’m not responsible for it. You are.” When she whines and complains that she needs help on the potty I close the door and ignore her and eventually she does it herself, hand washing included. When she wants something from an adult (a balloon animal at the fair, placing an order for food at a restaurant) I have her do it herself- sometimes I have to step in and translate, but by and large she can communicate herself. If she’s reluctant I say “If you want a balloon animal, you will have to go ask for it. I’m not going to do it.” If she wants it badly enough, she will do it herself, otherwise, she’ll go without. I want her to be able to speak up for herself with adults.

    As for chores, she clears her place after dinner, she puts her dirty clothes in the hamper. She helps me with laundry (hanging stuff up, which I have to redo so it will actually dry, putting things in the washer/dryer). She helps with cleaning up toys when asked.

    Setting the table and clearing the table I remind her, “Mommy made the dinner, Daddy does the dishes after dinner, you have to help out by setting/clearing the table.” When she’s particularly reluctant, I remind her of the story of The Little Red Hen and threaten to not share the dinner I make with her if she doesn’t help!
    Momma, PhD recently posted…Wordless Wednesday: Teach the controversyMy Profile

  4. Kristen says:

    I totally agree with this, and yet I find that I am often gently accused of being “too hard” on my 6 year old because we don’t pay her an allowance for the minimal daily chores she has (putting the cloth napkins in the laundry after dinner, filling the toilet paper holders 1x a week, cleaning her room 1x a week, and a few other small things). There are jobs that she can earn money for if she chooses, but there is a baseline of household responsibilities that she has that are unpaid, just like us adults. I also recently started letting her cook her own scrambled egg (supervised of course!) because using the stove is a big responsibility, having her choose the produce at the market, and placing her own orders at the post office/frozen yogurt stand/pizza place. If we ever want her to be self-sufficient and independent, we need to teach her these things along the way. I see so many smart, older teenagers/college aged kids who get into elite colleges yet can’t even do a load of laundry by themselves. To me, that’s ridiculous–what is going to serve that kid longer? Attending Psych 101 or knowing when to choose the gentle cycle? She’s pretty good about fulfilling her responsibilities and we see that it gives her confidence. Even when she balks, I just stand firm and tell myself it’s all for her own good down the road (and ours if we ever want her to move out before she’s 30!) 🙂 Great post – thank you!
    Kristen recently posted…ReadyMy Profile

  5. Lindsey says:

    I love this. It also depresses me, honestly, reading those parent stories. I know they are so true, and so all around me … makes me feel a little nauseous. But I am grateful to hear Christine’s points (again – I loved her book!) and to be reminded that independence and self-reliance, both values I care deeply about, are important to foster from day one. xox

  6. This is a great way to transition from the hoverparenting topic. We can use many of the same techniques which allow our children to explore their own social and physical abilities to teach responsibility and manners. You illustrated this wonderfully with your itemized list. I glommed onto the quote you used about taking advantage of a child’s early interest to participate in helping at home. Who cares if you have to refold the laundry? By given them an early start, chances are they’ll be good at in no time and become truly helpful contributors to the family and eventually society.

  7. I have found my 17 month old loves to help mom do her chores. I give her tasks, and she is so very happy to complete them. Her favorite is to pick up the dryer balls when we do laundry together. She will chase a ball all the way down the hall and bring it back to the dryer.
    She also likes to sweep with her little broom, and she even mimics how I fold diapers.

    Kids want to do what grown ups do. If we made it seem less like work, and more like fun, they will follow along!
    Itzybellababy recently posted…Wordless Wednesday, Hockey is coming!My Profile

  8. Katia says:

    Much like yourself I find it very hard to surrender control for the same reason, knowing that things will get done so much quicker if I do them myself. Being a tired parent wears your patience thin and quick solutions become your modus vivendi. I absolutely agree with the points that Loh Gross is making and will say that I have recently started voicing my expectations of my four-year-old more clearly.
    Katia recently posted…How Life With 4-Year-Old is Just Like Being in The Mob. I Would Imagine.My Profile

  9. Kate says:

    Great Post. There are great things on your list. Especially give kids tasks to do, making them feel responsible. My just now two year old loves to help. His proudest moment is when he helps me unload the dishwasher. He is proud and it helps teach him. Thank you for linking up with Wine’d Down Wednesday. Hope to see another great post from you next week.
    Kate recently posted…Wine’d Down WednesdayMy Profile

  10. Oh I struggle with this!! I have tried so many different methods to get my girls to do chores. Even though they should, they just don’t seem to “get it” – a clean house is not important to them and they aren’t bothered by the mess. Asking them to clean leads to whining & complaining. It is just so much easier for me to do it myself. I know that is not teaching them responsibility and that I should work harder to get them to do their fair share. It is surely a struggle and I haven’t yet found the right balance!
    Lisa @ The Golden Spoons recently posted…Ten Reasons Why Tweens Are Better Than ToddlersMy Profile

  11. Okay I’m scrolling down to say this now as I know I’ll forget to say this by the end of the actual point of your post, but I was just chastised by my son’s teacher on Thursday. We picked him up early to go to a wedding out of state. I said “clean up your lunch” and then he ran around all excited I was there. His teacher pointed out to me that I told him to clean up his lunch and then did it myself. Huh. Ok sorry moving on to read the rest…

    Um sorry scrolling down again because the parent who wanted her kid placed away from the boy with mild rocking? Should be punched.

    I used to walk home from school. In 7th grade, I was threatened with gang rape and luckily, it never happened. But it wasn’t the deal it would be today. Honestly, I’m not sure whether that’s good or bad.
    Kristi Campbell recently posted…When Music Transports me Back In TimeMy Profile

  12. Woah: “There was the parent who hid in the bushes (taking notes) during recess because she wanted to keep track of who her son played with at recess.” That is creepy.

    I agree that it’s really hard to force a toddler to do all these things. I’m so out of time as it is — and he’s not even 2! Imagine how much less time I will have when he’s older. I have to be better about it, too….
    Deb @ Urban Moo Cow recently posted…UntitledMy Profile

  13. Great post! I’m also a former teacher turned mom…the boys are 14 and 17 now, but I continue to be amazed by what parents do for their kiddos. The kids suffer, become helpless adults, and then the parents complain how helpless they are…I know how hard ti can be when it’s your own child, but parents need to try to keep the long-term goal in mind.
    Bonnie a.k.a. LadyBlogger recently posted…Time For A Blog Hop!My Profile

  14. Thank you for addressing this topic!

    My four and six-year-old both help around the house, sometimes reluctantly. My daughter picks up the million shoes that find their way all over the floor, and her older brother vacuums. They both put their clean clothes away, help empty the dishwasher, feed the dog, and clear their dishes. My boy makes his lunch every day, and he did that as a kindergartner, too. My preschooler helps make her lunch on school days. They can both make simple breakfasts, and my boy was granted access to the toaster oven last month, after a probationary period where we carefully observed him putting bread in and taking toast out.

    I see the difference in my kids’ self-sufficiency compared to some of their peers, and am happy to trade imperfect silverware drawers and closets for independent children. My job is to present my children to adult society with knowledge, skills, and abilities, not to cook and clean for them as long as they live here.
    Amy – Funny is Family recently posted…15 Things I’ve Learned In My First Year Of BloggingMy Profile

  15. adrienne says:

    I think every parent who spends much time with their kids quickly realizes that it’s easier (in the short run) to simply do tasks his or her self.

    My professional life has been university advising, so I’m blessed with the experience of knowing a multitude of young adults who were starting to leave home.

    There are times when I pause in my work, assess the difficulty of the task, and reassign duties to my children.

    My second-grader makes his lunch before school and has since first grade. To enable this, I had to move most of the lunch fixings to lower shelves and a crate on the floor of the pantry. It’s a huge relief for me not to scramble to assemble lunch while getting everyone ready for school.

    He’s proud of his efforts (and gets complimented on them by friends and family), and he can even get snacks or a quick breakfast for himself and his younger sisters.

    We’re a team in the morning- each with our own jobs to do, and I like that a lot.

    Recently, I was about to send his school a check prepaying for a year’s worth of weekly treats, and I realized that maybe wasn’t in his best interest long-term.

    Ultimately, we want these little people to be able to take care of themselves and others. It’s a lot harder to get a crash course in responsibility at 18 or 22 than it is to learn incrementally (and with much lower stakes) in those first 18 years. The kids who master these life skills in the early years have lot more time to dream big during their early adulthood (and beyond).
    adrienne recently posted…Not Paying For Popcorn: Elementary School EconomicsMy Profile

  16. Materials pop up demonstrates can supply eye-popping visuals to support the attention with observers. The fabric remains to be linked to the structure this means you will change from folded for you to positiioned in moments. A person most essential facet of all these demonstrates is they needs to be anti aging as well as fireresistant.
    ニューバランス レディース 996 http://www.childrenshopeinaction.org/images/newblance.html

  17. My programmer is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on various websites for about a year and am anxious about switching to another platform. I have heard good things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress posts into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated!
    basket jordan femme pas cher http://surreytwinclub.com/air_jordan_femme.html

  18. Chelsea says:

    Pretty great post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to mention that I have
    really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    In any case I’ll be subscribing on your feed and I’m hoping you
    write again very soon!
    Chelsea recently posted…ChelseaMy Profile

  19. phuquoc city says:

    It has something for everyone and you can expect nothing
    lesser than one of the best experiences every time you visit the area.
    This miraculous state of India is blessed with some
    of the best gift of nature that’s why it is also popular by the name “gateway of nature”.
    But one of the main reasons why you go for a vacation is because you want to rejuvenate your body and mind.
    phuquoc city recently posted…phuquoc cityMy Profile

  20. However, as with any popular destination, many of the best known attractions get overcrowded with tourists, which can taint the experience.
    Splendid architecture of the citadels, royal tombs,
    palaces and temples is marvelous site. The wide variety of
    quality products coupled with their economical prices entice
    visitors to try their hands at shopping.
    vietnam tourism recently posted…vietnam tourismMy Profile

  21. Charline says:

    This is because this kind of snow pants come underneath your kid.

    It can help to freely express your kid’s look since it is
    not based on the conventional mode of dressing.
    All-in-one ski suits could also cause problems when nature calls and you suddenly
    end up dashing to the nearest toilet.
    Charline recently posted…CharlineMy Profile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge